Racial Violence

Author: Lucius Seger

Extrajudicial violence against marginalized groups in Texas undergirds much of the state’s history. During the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, the proliferation and racialization of mobs helped to explain the intricate, pervasive, and contradictory ideology of White Texans. Previously seen as an overlooked topic among academic historians, the field of racial violence has grown considerably in the last two decades. Yet, much work remains to decouple prevailing biases within primary sources to understand more nuances on how racial violence affected Black, Mexican American, and other marginalized communities throughout the state.

Five Secondary Sources: 

1) Terry Anne Scott, Lynching and Leisure: Race and the Transformation of Mob Violence in Texas (University of Arkansas Press, 2022).

Terry Anne Scott’s 2022 Lynching and Leisure connects the racialization of lynching in Texas by the end of the nineteenth century to the cultural components that commercialized these episodes of racial violence as a leisure activity for White Texans. Scott argues that understanding the transformation of the new lynching culture into a recreational activity for many White Texans is essential to comprehending the motives behind racial violence toward Black Texans. From analyzing racial violence in the Reconstruction era to the infamous lynching of Jesse Washington in 1916, the author makes important historiographic interventions to understanding White attitudes toward lynching by analyzing how White Texans purchased postcards depicting a lynching, toured sites of racial violence, and took trains to see extrajudicial violence against Black Texans. These prevailing attitudes among many White Texans in the late nineteenth and early twentieth century interpreted lynching as a socially acceptable recreational activity that frequently devalued the humanity of the Black Americans.  

Lynching and Leisure

2) William D. Carrigan, The Making of a Lynching Culture: Violence and Vigilantism in Central Texas, 1836-1916 (University of Illinois Press, 2006).

In this pathbreaking book, Carrigan studies how cultural memory helped White Texans justify extrajudicial violence against Black Texans, Mexican Americans, Native Americans, and White political dissenters. Looking back at settler violence against indigenous peoples and the foundations of slavery, the author adeptly shows how the extrajudicial violence in Central Texas was built on the backs of White Texans’ localized narratives glorifying violence against any marginalized group that broke the racialized hierarchical order of nineteenth and early twentieth century Texas. While only covering a specific geographic area, this work is one of the most influential books on racial violence in Texas because it explores the background of racial violence in the nineteenth century and expands its focus away from episodes of singular racial violence to look at the broader history of lynching influencing the racialization of extrajudicial violence in the early twentieth century.

3) Monica Muñoz Martinez, The Injustice Never Leaves You: Anti-Mexican Violence in Texas (Harvard University Press, 2018)

Monica Muñoz Martinez’s seismic book The Injustice Never Leaves You analyses the anti-Mexican violence committed by state authorities such as the Texas Rangers during the 1910s. Looking at specific instances of Anglo vigilante justice in 1910, 1915, and 1918, Martinez elucidated how White fears over the Mexican Revolution in the Texas Borderlands led to a period of beatings, intimidation, and extrajudicial violence toward ethnic Mexicans. Writing against the glorification of the Texas Rangers, the author uses oral history interviews and other sources to recover an alternative perspective of the ethnic Mexicans who pushed for public accountability and the survival of their communities in the face of this violence. This book adroitly cuts against the grain to uncover names of ethnic Mexicans who were killed by White mobs and authorities to help better remember some of the previously marginalized episodes of violence that took place during La Matanza (the massacre) in the 1910s.

4) Gary B. Borders, A Hanging in Nacogdoches: Murder, Race, Politics, and Polemics in Texas’s Oldest Town, 1870-1916 (University of Texas Press, 2006)

Gary Borders’ 2006 A Hanging in Nacogdoches analyses the 1902 publicly hanging of a Black man, Jim Buchanan, for the alleged murder of three White residents of the city. Analyzing the economic and political dimensions of late nineteenth century Nacogdoches, Borders’ well-researched microhistory delves into the complicated history of the oldest town in Texas and the proliferation of racial tensions during the height of the third-party Populist movement during the 1890s. Borders’ book goes into the complicated histories of legal lynching as local officials hung Buchannan immediately after an expediated trial to prevent a potential gruesome episode of extrajudicial violence. This work showcases the local nature of lynchings and how the intricate local politics and deteriorating race relations of Jim Crow Texas help historians understand the root causes of racial violence against Black Texans during the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries.

5) Bruce A. Glasrud, Anti-Black Violence in Twentieth-Century Texas (Texas A&M University Press, 2015)

Glasrud’s important 2015 edited monograph Anti-Black Violence in Twentieth-Century Texas compiles twelve infamous episodes of anti-Black violence throughout the twentieth century in Texas to understand the context and motivations behind these violent episodes. Looking from the lynching of Henry Smith in 1893 to the racially motivated beating of Billy Ray Johnson in 2003, this book seeks to encapsulate the White attitudes justifying racial violence and the failures to memorialize many of these events in the Lone Star State. Glasrud’s edited collection elaborates on lesser remembered racial events after the decline of lynchings by the 1940s to show the continuation of many incidents of race-based violence in the twenty-first century. This collection makes an important contribution to the historiography of racial violence through its extensive depth in connecting past racial violence to more recent episodes in Texas’s history.

Five Primary Sources: 

1) “Riot at Millican,” the Texas Countryman, July 22, 1868

From July 15-17, a serious racial disturbance broke out in the small town of Millican, located in Brazos County in southeast central Texas, which killed anywhere from 5 to 150 Black residents of the town. Set in the backdrop of Reconstruction and the advent of the First Ku Klux Klan, racial tensions following the Civil War frequently spilled over into episodes of racial violence due to White fears over Black social and political advancement. In this particular incident, a rumor spread that a White landowner named Holliday had killed a Black man. In response, a Black militia organized and was met by a White posse. After a gun discharged, full-scale violence broke out as White militia indiscriminately killed African Americans. This document reveals not only some of the racial biases of contemporary White Texans but also the effects that mob violence has on communities of color throughout the state.

2) H.W. Chinn Letter to Governor Culberson, July 1, 1897

Written in 1897, this letter, from a Waller County Merchant, H.W. Chinn, to Governor Charles Culberson, goes over the intricate details of the lynching of five Black men. On April 29, 1897, a masked mob hung five Black Texans for the alleged murder of a Black man and the killing and sexual assault of a Black woman and girl in Southeastern Texas. After questions were raised over the suspected innocence of some of the victims, Governor Culberson condemned the lynching and called for a further investigation into the manner. In this letter, Chinn justifies the lynching on the fact that several of the victims purportedly had a reputation for sexual assault and that the local sheriff was drunk when summoned by the governor to report about the situation. This source uncovers White Texans’ growing justifications for racialized lynchings that connected Black men to the perceived increase in sexual assaults on women and children.

3) “Testimony of Rosenda Mega,” Excerpt, Proceedings of the Joint Committee of the Senate and the House in the Investigation of the Texas State Ranger Force. Archives and Information Services Division, Texas State Library and Archives Commission

This report was taken from the Canales Investigation, which was a legislative committee formed to hear about abuses and vigilante violence toward people of Mexican descent from the Texas Rangers in 1919. Following reports of ethnically motivated violence and murder against Tejanos by state forces, the only Latino legislator, José Tomás Canales, helped usher in an investigation to confront some of the abuses. Despite threats to his life and the end of his political career, Canales’ investigation unearthed testimonies describing the violence and racial prejudice exhibited during La Matanza, a historical period of anti-Mexican violence in Texas between 1910 and 1920. In this sworn testimony, an American, Rosenda Mega, describes how a group of forty US troops, Texas Rangers, and White ranchers, surrounded a ranch outside of Porvenir, Texas near the Mexican-United States border. After taking the ranch, the Texas Rangers took fifteen male inhabitants outside of the ranch and executed them: revealing the pervasive nature of racial violence on the southern border against Mexican-descent people during the early twentieth century.

4) “Governor Hogg’s Action,” The Galveston Daily News, February 3, 1893.

On February 1, 1893, a mob of citizens from Lamar County and the surrounding areas burned alive a Black man named Henry Smith for the alleged murder and sexual assault of a Whit girl, Myrtle Vance. In the aftermath of this event, many White Texans attempted to justify the lynching and torture of Smith for such a “heinous crime.” This primary source document delves into some of the common justifications for extrajudicial violence against Black men through leading lawyers and citizens justifying the brutality of the lynching based on the alleged crime committed. In this document, there is also pushback against Governor James S. Hogg’s verbally condemnation of the event and attempts to stop the lynching from taking, showcasing the tensions between executive’s attempting to curb lawlessness and local communities’ demands to enforce violence on perceived breaks of the racial hierarchy.

5) Mobbing of John Shillady Secretary of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People at Austin. Texas, Aug.22, 1919

On August 22, 1919, a local county judge, constable, and other Texas citizens assaulted the executive secretary of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP), a White man, John R. Shillady, for allegedly stoking racial tensions in the city of Austin. Shillady had arrived at the city to understand why the Governor of Texas, William P; Hobby, was investigating the local Austin branch of the NAACP. After the man was unable to talk to any major official, local law enforcement shadowed Shillady until they assaulted him and forced the secretary to leave town. This primary source helps to understand how early NAACP activism met resistance from local White officials who believed that outside forces were trying to promote exacerbate race relations.

Further Research

Necessary Interventions:

  1. While great work has been done on this topic, there needs to be more study on the lynching of Mexican American Texans and a greater connection to the effects of mob violence on Black Texans.
  2. Historians need to read between the lines in White sources and add more Black/Hispanic perspectives to understand the impact of lynching on these communities.
  3. There needs to be more focus on utilizing historical works to advocate for memorialization/plaques of these mob violence episodes across Texas.

Two Archives:

  1. NAACP Papers, Part 07: The Anti-Lynching Campaign, 1912-1955, Library of Congress
    This is a collection of letters, reports, newspaper clippings, pamphlets, and correspondence from the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP)’s attempt to publicize the lynchings of Black Americans and promote anti-lynching legislation from 1912 to 1955. This collection includes numerous clippings, correspondence, and testimonies from infamous lynchings or episodes of racial violence, such as in Waco (1916), Longview (1919), Sherman (1930), and proposed statewide anti-lynching legislation and works condemning mob violence, such as in 1919. Most of the collection is available through ProQuest, which is not open access. Moreover, there are some NAACP records on the Library of Congress’s website; however, there is only one document about lynching available as of now.
  2. Texas State Library and Archives Commission’s Governor’s Records, Austin, TX
    This is a collection of governor’s records held at the Texas State Library and Archives Commission (TSLAC)’s main building in Austin, Texas. Most of the sources in this collection are incoming and outgoing letters, newspaper clippings, telegrams, and governmental reports on forty-seven Texas governors from the mid-nineteenth century to the twenty-first century. Many letters sent to political figures like Governors Edmund J. Davis (1870-1874), James S. Hogg (1891-1895), and Charles A. Culberson (1895-1899) received correspondence from local Texans on matters regarding specific episodes of racial violence throughout this time period. Only a select few governor’s records have been digitized, and the rest of the documents are available in-person at the TSLAC’s building in Austin.

Lucius Seger is a PhD candidate in history at Texas Christian University. His research looks at the connection of anti-lynching politics with extrajudicial violence in Texas during the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. Lucius received the 2025 Portal to Texas History Research Fellowship Award sponsored by the University of North Texas for his project and current dissertation titled Lynching and the Law: An Analysis of Mob Violence in Texas, 1874-1919.   Lucius graduated with a BA in history from Wright State University in 2019 and with an MA from the University of Cincinnati in 2021.